Sunday, July 13, 2014

Criticisms of Piaget's Theory

Some researchers identified shortcomings in Piaget's theory. Piaget is criticized because much of his early research was limited to his three children. However, these small samples are generally considered too small to be reliable (Henson & Eller, 1999) .Some researchers believe Piaget may have underestimated the importance of experience and the effects in learning of cognitive development during the age of 2-7 and also they mentioned the tasks were overly difficult and confusing (Henson & Eller, 1999). Another criticisms of Piaget's theory, he believed in a particular stage would be similar across tasks. Such as, all the cognitive tasks of preschool children should do according to preoperational level in preschools, but researchers found different in children's thinking across cognitive tasks   (Wood, Smith, & Grossniklaus, 2011). The researchers also found in Piaget theory, he did not consider the effects of cultural variation. The abilities of concrete operations may not be common and learnt at the same stage. The concrete operations differ from cultural vise and seem not same order in children of different cultural environments (Henson & Eller, 1999).
Image;http://www.sciencebuzz.org/image/jean-piaget-and-constance-kamii

Application of the theory to the classroom/teaching.

The goals of the theory is to prepare students to do new things they have never done and as to prepare students to think more logically. He also suggested that students learn activity (Henson & Eller, 1999).  Therefore, we must create an environment in which students can be active and will be able to initiate and compare their activities and give chance to make errors and learn through their mistakes. Teachers have to use concrete props and visual aids whenever possible. Students need encouragement to learn, however, teachers have provide many opportunities for learners to explore and experiment. The tasks should be designed to work together with different abilities level of students. (Wood, Smith, & Grossniklaus, 2011). The instruction should be clear and make sure presentation and reading are brief and well organized. When you introduce complex ideas use familiar examples and give opportunities to classify. For the young learners provide multiples of experiences in order to build a foundation for concept learning and language. For the adolescence and adults learners give opportunities to explore many hypothetical question and to solve problems by reasoning scientifically (Woolfolk, 2001).  
Image;http://long-straight-haircuts.blogspot.com/2013/01/cognitive-development-in-children.html

Different development stages and learning

Piaget’s first stage of development is sensorimotor. The stage begins at the birth and lasts until 18 months-2 years of age. In this stage children use the movement skill senses or motor activity and other senses to explore and learn the world. During this stage, children start to see the relation between goals and the means to reach the goal, and they begin to use symbolic thought (Henson & Eller, 1999). In this stage knowledge is limited, because the thinking is based on physical interactions and experiences.  When the children begin to mobile or become more mobile, increases the cognitive development. At the birth, the infant’s only behavior are reaction to the environment but about the age of 2 most children start react to their own thinking (Henson & Eller, 1999).
Piaget refers the preoperational period as the second stage of cognitive development. This stage‘s children are 2- 7 years. During this stage children begin to use language. The major characteristic of children during this period is the development of symbolic modes of representation (Henson & Eller, 1999).Even though children use their symbolic thinking ability to solve problems their thinking still is limited in several ways. Since they have limited conversation skills and do not follow the convention of logic. Children of this stage get easily deceived and difficult to follow others perception (Yunus, Razli, & jantan, 2011). In the preoperational stage, children can understand and express relationships between the past and the future. During this stage their intelligence is egocentric and intuitive (Wood, Smith, & Grossniklaus, 2011).
Piaget’s third phase of “hands –on” thinking   stage of cognitive development, he coined the term concrete operations to describe (Woolfolk A. E., 1995). The concrete operational stage typically develops between the ages of 7-11 years. During this stage children begin the recognition of the logical stability of the physical world. So they demonstrate through the use of logical and systematic manipulation of symbols, which are related to concrete objects. Another important operation children master at this stage is classification. They have ability to focus on a single characteristic of objects in a set and group the objects according to that characteristic (Woolfolk A. E., 1995). Thinking becomes less egocentric with improved awareness of outside events and the world, use more of concrete references and solve problems through trial error (Wood, Smith, & Grossniklaus, 2011).

The final stage of Piaget’s cognitive development is formal operation. This stage can start at the age of 11 or 12.During this stage individuals begin to use concepts that they have never encounter and they can use objects that they cannot actively manipulate. Children in the formal operation can draw inferences and make predictions to solve the problems. (Henson & Eller, 1999).Piaget believed that intellectual development was a lifelong process, but when attain the formal operational thought, the new structures are not needed. Adults’ Intellectual development involves developing more complicated schema through the addition of knowledge (Wood, Smith, & Grossniklaus, 2011). Researches show there are people never reach this stage of cognitive development (Henson & Eller, 1999).
Image;http://childpsych.umwblogs.org/files/2011/10/Piaget_1.jpg

Piaget’s Theory of Cognitive Development


Piaget’s observation of children, that he found children were creating ideas. The reception knowledge from parents and teachers was not limited and they actively constructed their own knowledge (Wood, Smith, & Grossniklaus, 2011). According to Piaget organizing and adaptation are the two important processes in building and understanding about the world around them. One of the basic tendencies in thinking is organization. These psychological ongoing processes allow combining, arranging recombining and reordering of behaviors and thought into mental systems or categories. Such as, very young infants can either look at an object or grasp it when it comes in contact with their hands. They cannot coordinate looking and grasping at the same time. As they develop the behaviors, they organize these two separate behavioral structures into a coordinated higher-level structure of looking at, reaching for, grasping the object (Woolfolk, 2001).
Adaptation is the tendencies to organize the psychological structures. We also need to inherit the tendency to adapt to their environment by fitting information into existing schemes and alerting schemes or creating new ones in responsible to new information (Woolfolk, 2001).However, the readiness is important for the level of mental development necessary to learn from experiences. Children cannot gain benefit from experiences until they reach the cognitive level of thought that will allow them to understand those experiences (Henson & Eller, 1999).

He believed children develop their understanding about the surroundings through four stages of cognitive development (Yunus, Razli, & Jantan, 2011). The identified four stages are sensorimotor, preoperational, concrete operational and formal operational. According to Piaget all children under goes all the stages one or two or more stages to progress to the next level of cognitive development. In each level, children show new intellectual abilities and develop complex understanding of the world.  The ages at which children progress through the stages are averages they differ with the environment and upbringing of individual children (Wood, Smith, & Grossniklaus, 2011).
Image;http://www.friendshipcircle.org/blog/2013/02/25/8-great-toys-that-help-with-cognitive-development/

Introduction



The certain changes that occur in human beings or animals between conception and death called development in its most general psychological sense. The development is not applied to all changes that occur while human development, such as a temporary changes causes by a brief illnesses, but rather o those that appears in systematic ways and remain for a reasonably long period of time. Human development can be divided into a number of different aspects (Woolfolk, 2001).


One of the aspects is cognitive development. It considers gradual orderly changes on mental processes, which become more complex and sophisticated (Woolfolk, 2001).Most important person behind this theory was the psychologist Jean Piaget. He was a famous child psychologist. His theory provided detailed information of children’s cognitive development. Most of Piaget’s theory was develop through his research with three children of his own (Henson & Eller, 1999).

Image: Unidentified (Ensian published by University of Michigan) - 1968 Michiganensian, p. 91

Discussion Forum

Piaget's Theory